Carrick’s position has come under significant threat this season with Emery among United’s list of managerial targets should a change be made in the dugout.
The topic was discussed on this week’s ‘Stick to Football’ with Carragher praising the work Emery has done during his four years at Villa Park.
The former England defender also referred to ‘the chain in football’, explaining players and managers will always consider moving onto bigger challenges.
‘Aston Villa will never be Manchester United. I just think he didn’t do well at PSG or Arsenal, and maybe that’s because of egos in the dressing room and that sort of thing,’ Carragher told Stick to Football.
‘But surely he would want that opportunity to manage a giant again. There is a chain in football, whether you like it or not.
Emery’s work at Villa has been universally praised (Picture: Getty Images Europe)
‘So Real Madrid will take Manchester United’s best player, they did it with [Cristiano] Ronaldo. And there will be teams below Aston Villa, and they’ll take their players or manager, so shut the f**k up Aston Villa fans. Aston Villa will never be Manchester United.’
On Friday evening Villa released a statement on social media, signed by chairman Nassef Sawiris, accusing Carragher of insulting the club and its supporters, warning they will ‘initiate legal action.’
Carragher has now issued his own statement, insisting his comments were’tongue in cheek.’
‘I’d like to apologise to Aston Villa, the owners and their fans,’ Carragher wrote on X.
‘My language this week was clumsy and wrong. I can assure Villa fans it was tongue in cheek but I can understand it’s not come across that way, so apologies.
In this week’s edition of The Football Interview, Kelly Somers speaks to former Premier League striker and pundit Alan Shearer. They speak about his Premier League goalscoring record, leaving Newcastle for Southampton as a teenager and winning the Premier League with Blackburn Rovers. They discuss Alan Shearer the football fan and the feeling when Newcastle won the League Cup in 2025, their first trophy in his lifetime.
TIME CODES
00:25: Propensity for timeliness
01:35: Leaving Newcastle for Southampton
02:50: Joining Blackburn Rovers
03:50: Premier League's record goalscorer
04:33: Playing for Newcastle United
07:34: The pressure of becoming Newcastle manager
08:43: Punditry
10:18: Passion for charity work
11:52: The best football matches witnessed
12:50: Being a fan post-playing career
Liverpool have bounced back impressively from their 3-0 defeat to Manchester City earlier this month, winning five straight games in all competitions.
The Reds impressively beat third-place Brighton last weekend and can now look to further close the gap on the top two when they host defending champions Arsenal at Anfield.
Writing in The Telegraph, Carragher asserted that Liverpool could rubber-stamp their title credentials with a win against the Gunners, particularly given the uncertainty surrounding City after their guilty verdict.
But Iraola suggested it was too early to engage with that kind of title talk and said his team still needed to ‘improve’.
‘I think it is too early to start looking at the standings,’ Iraola said in his pre-match press conference. ‘It is about preparing ourselves for a very difficult game.
‘We know Arsenal and how good they are. They have very good players, working a lot in synchronicity and we have to be ready for that challenge.
Liverpool boss Andoni Iraola (Picture: Getty)
‘It’s going to be a demanding game but we also trust our players, trust ourselves and in the good atmosphere we will for sure have on Sunday, I hope we will be at level to win this game.
‘It is still October,’ he continued. ‘We have to take one game at a time and I always say the reference is more or less when we’ve play against each other once so halfway through the season. That’s when you can start to look at the standings.
‘Right now, we are in a position where wneed to improve and keep getting better.
‘For fans, it is good if they have expectations or they think we can win. Normally that’s a good thing but if you ask me if I think it is still very early in the season.’
Liverpool will hope to be boosted by the return of Dominik Szoboszlai and Víctor Munoz for Sunday’s game as they continue their recoveries from hamstring and knee injuries, respectively.
‘I think they have a chance,’ Iraola added. ‘But I don’t know for sure if they will be involved or not. We still have two days, so I think they have a chance, yes.’
John Murray, Alistair Bruce-Ball and Ian Dennis are back after the Carabao Cup quarter finals.
Ian still has the Captain Pugwash theme in his ears as he recounts a historic evening for Fleetwood.
Which member of the team has the same name as Martin Clunes' dogs?
We have lots of suggestions for rhyming slang footballers and an unusual Clash of the Commentators as John takes on Ian.
TIMECODES
01:00 Fleetwood + Captain Pugwash
05:00 League Cup reflections
09:45 Weekend fixtures
17:00 Rhyming slang
22:50 Footballing tongue twisters
28:55 Clash of the Commentators
38:55 Unintended Pub Name
41:05 Great Glossary of football
5 Live/BBC Sounds commentaries this weekend
SAT 1500: Manchester City v Brighton (Premier League) - 5 Live
SAT 1500: Coventry City v Sunderland (Premier League) - Sports Extra 2
SAT 1500: Motherwell v St Mirren (Scottish Premiership) - Sports Extra 3
SAT 1730: Tottenham v Crystal Palace (Premier League) - 5 Live
SAT 1730: Rangers v Aberdeen (Scottish League Cup) - Sports Extra 3
SUN 1200: London City Lionesses v Manchester City (Women’s Super League) - 5 Live
SUN 1300: Falkirk v Celtic (Scottish Premiership) - Sports Extra 2
SUN 1500: Hearts v Hibernian (Scottish League Cup) - Sports Extra 2
SUN 1630: Liverpool v Arsenal (Premier League) - 5 Live
Great Glossary of Football
DIVISION ONE
10 men behind the ball
50p head
Agricultural challenge,
Back of the net,
Back to square one,
Backside and elbows,
The Beautiful Game,
Booked,
Bosman,
Bullet header,
Buying a penalty,
Caretaker manager,
Channel of joy,
Checked and cleared,
Coupon buster,
Cross-come-shot
Cruyff Turn,
Cultured/educated left foot,
Dead-ball specialist,
Draught excluder,
Elastico/flip-flap,
False nine,
Fox in the box,
Game’s gone
Giving the goalkeeper the eyes,
Grub hunter,
Header
Head like a biscuit tin,
Head like a sheriff’s badge,
Head tennis,
Hibs it,
In a good moment,
In behind,
Lollipop,
Magic of the FA Cup,
“Make sure you watch Match of the Day tonight”
The Maradona,
Need one to get in off their backside,
Off their line,
Olimpico,
Onion bag,
Panenka,
Parachute payment,
Park the bus,
Perfect hat-trick,
Postage stamp,
Put his cap on it,
Rabona,
Roy of the Rovers stuff,
Schmeichel-style,
Scorpion kick,
Spursy,
Stick it in the mixer,
Sweeper keeper,
Taking it to the corner flag,
Target man,
Tiki-taka,
Tipped it over the bar
Towering header,
Trivela,
UEFA penalty,
Where the kookaburra sleeps,
Where the owl sleeps,
Where the spiders sleep,
You could have two goalkeepers in there and they still wouldn’t have saved it.
Gyokeres arrived at the Emirates last summer, and amassed a respectable 22 goals in all competitions over the course of his debut season in English football.
However, the Swedish striker has clearly fallen down the pecking order at the start of the season, starting only one of Arsenal’s first eight games in the Premier League.
Gyokeres scored his first goal of the season in midweek against Fleetwood Town, but Richards believes the 28-year-old still looks short of confidence and faces an uncertain future at the Emirates.
‘When he first arrived at Arsenal, I was saying to the Arsenal fans, “Don’t expect him to be scoring 25 and 30 goals”.
‘What I really liked about him, he was good at running in behind, but he stopped doing the things that he’s really good at.
Viktor Gyokeres has scored one goal so far this season (Picture: Getty)
‘He sort of looks like he has no confidence. I don’t know if the reports in the summer that they tried to get rid of him [were true] or not, but essentially he’s had enough game time to show what he can do now at Arsenal and it’s just not happening for him.’
Analysing how Arsenal might address Gyokeres’ lack of form when the transfer window reopens, Richards added: ‘I think in January, because of the injuries, I definitely think they should go back into the market, and find top cover around.
‘Because the way Arsenal play, and everyone talks about they need this player, they need that player, but the reason why they’re so good is what the front players do off the ball… so, Saka and Madueke work hard in a system that works for Arsenal.
Gyokeres has started only one Premier League match this season (Picture: Getty)
‘Obviously, losing Trossard was a big miss for them in terms of what he does off the ball and how clinical he was with the opportunities given to him.
‘But I think if they want to compete and then, say, dominate, then 100 per cent, I think they need more firepower in that forward area, for sure.
‘There are so many times where Gyokeres gets in really good positions, and I don’t know if he doesn’t back himself, I don’t know if it’s confidence, I don’t know if the team doesn’t back him to score, but he just, he doesn’t put the ball away. So, then it becomes a problem.
‘And I just feel like he needs one of those opportunities where he plays 90 minutes, he scores, he builds confidence, and it goes from there.
‘Otherwise, you know, they’re going to have to look to move him on.’
And Gary Lineker echoed Richards’s sentiments, with the former England striker saying: ‘I don’t see him as a starting nine, particularly for a club of the stature of Arsenal.
‘I think he can come off the bench and do a bit. I think he’s probably more of a squad player.’
Fernandes watched from the bench as United lost to Bournemouth last weekend after calling Michael Carrick’s tactics into question following a 4-1 defeat to Como.
The Red Devils captain is expected to return to the fold against Chelsea on Saturday, but has a cloud hanging over him following his public falling out with the manager.
Fernandes was United’s standout performer last season, managing 30 goal involvements in 35 games to help his side finish third after a poor start under Ruben Amorim.
The 32-year-old has a £57million release clause in his contract, but seemingly spurned interest from Saudi Arabia to remain at Old Trafford for his eighth season.
But after a dismal and chaotic start to the season, former Arsenal striker Wright believes that Fernandes may already be regretting that decision.
‘I backed him because of what he had achieved up to that point,’ Wright said on The Overlap with Sky Bet.
Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes (Picture: AFP)
‘He’s dragged that team, done a lot of work himself and is probably frustrated now.
‘He’s given his best years to United and there’s no way he won’t be thinking he should have left.
‘It’s not even a case of where [he could have gone], he will be thinking, “I could have done this, I could have done that”.
‘The fact is, I thought he would have changed his attitude and the way he is and he wouldn’t be poisonous in the dressing room.
Michael Carrick dropped Fernandes against Bournemouth (Picture: Getty)
‘But I genuinely believe he was the one loading the gun for Martinez and then the way that he came out afterwards and threw Michael under the bus, you see that he must be a nightmare in that dressing room.’
Despite his public comments, Fernandes will retain the club captaincy, with Carrick insisting the midfielder is ‘committed’ to United.
‘Listen, we’re clear with the situation of the team and as a football club at the moment,’ Carrick said in Thursday’s pre-match press conference.
‘He’s an important player for this group. He has been and he will be.
‘Between us, we’ve got to make a difference and we’ve got to push things in a good direction.
‘He’s fully committed to this football club, he’s fully committed to making things better. It doesn’t change for me. He’s the one that’s kind of led the team so well for many a game and many a year, and he’ll continue to do that.’
However, Grealish, who missed the 2-0 defeat to Arsenal in the Premier League last Saturday due to illness, was not included in David Moyes’ squad for the Carabao Cup tie at the Hill Dickinson Stadium due to a disciplinary issue.
It is understood that Grealish has been disciplined by Everton for an unauthorised absence from training.
The Times report that Grealish now faces a ‘hefty fine’ for his conduct.
‘Well, you probably know I am not going to give any details and it is a club decision,’ Moyes said after Everton’s win over Newcastle.
David Moyes says he supports Everton’s decision to discipline Jack Grealish (CameraSport via Getty)
‘I support the decision but it’s a club decision. It is something I don’t want to speak too much about. I feel as if the club are the people you should go to if you are looking for more on it.’
Everton’s press officer then intervened when Moyes was asked whether Grealish would be included in Everton’s squad for their Premier League game against Newcastle at St James’ Park on Monday night.
Grealish re-joined Everton in the summer transfer window on a second successive loan from Manchester City, a move which has cost the Toffees around £12 million per season.
The 31-year-old, who was signed in a £100m deal from Aston Villa in 2021, will see his contract with City expire at the end of the season.
Harrison Neal caught Dowman’s standing leg with a hefty challenge from behind on the touchline and replays clearly showed the 16-year-old Arsenal forward kick out at the Fleetwood midfielder in the heat of the moment.
The reigning Premier League champions have since launched an appeal against Dowman’s sending off. If the appeal is unsuccessful, the teenager will be suspended for the club’s next three top-flight matches against Liverpool, Hull City and Newcastle.
While Fleetwood’s against-all-odds win was undoubtedly the story of the fourth round, Arteta’s fiery meeting with Dowman on the edge of his technical area proved another major talking point from the contest.
Before Dowman made his way down the tunnel, the grim-faced Spaniard appeared to mutter a few choice words in the attacker’s ear, a reaction which has proven divisive amongst Arsenal’s fanbase.
Arteta was visibly unimpressed with Dowman after the youngster’s red card (Picture: Getty)
Arsenal have launched an appeal against Dowman’s sending off (Picture: Getty)
Asked what he had said to Dowman, Arteta told BBC Radio 5 Live: ‘Something that we discussed already before the match.’
On Dowman’s red card, the Arsenal boss added: ‘It’s difficult to see on the cameras like that.
‘I prefer to watch it back properly and then I can assess the situation.’
Up Next
Giving his thoughts on Tuesday’s absorbing cup tie, former Liverpool and Tottenham midfielder Redknapp passed on his congratulations to Fleetwood before focussing in on Dowman’s sending off.
According to Redknapp, Arteta’s reaction was over the top and he should have waited until he was in the changing room to give Dowman a dressing down.
‘I don’t think you can do that,’ Redknapp – who won the League Cup with Liverpool in 1995 – said on The Overlap.
Fleetwood will face either Everton on Newcastle in the quarter-finals (Picture: Daniel Weir/Sports Press Photo/Shutterstock)
‘That has to go back in the dressing room, you have to wait.
‘It was a very aggressive manner towards him. Just say nothing.
‘They should have put that game to bed before 85 minutes anyway.’
Dowman could be suspended for Arsenal’s next three league games (Picture: Sports Press Photo/Shutterstock)
Redknapp felt Fleetwood’s Neal was somewhat fortunate to escape unpunished after his ‘dangerous’ challenge on Dowman.
‘It was a dangerous tackle,’ the ex-England international added.
‘In our day, you’d just go, “What a tackle”, you’d be celebrating that one.
‘Every time you hook a player, you’re just risking hurting their knee and I suppose Dowman has just reacted.’
The 16-year-old was making his 18th appearance for the Gunners (Picture: Getty)
Tim Sherwood, sat opposite Redknapp in The Overlap studio, hopes Dowman is able to see the experience as part of a ‘learning curve’ at the start of his career.
‘He’s a wonderful talent, we all know that, and it’s a learning curve for him,’ the former Tottenham manager chimed in.
‘Unfortunately he’s going to pay the price because that’s where his game-time is going to come from, playing in that competition.
Dowman should see the sending off as part of his ‘learning curve’, says Sherwood (Picture: The Overlap)
‘Now, I know Bukayo Saka is injured so I hope he gets a few more opportunities but win and learn as a kid, win and learn.
‘It was a poor tackle and he’s probably never had tackles like that in the Under-21s.
Sherwood was somewhat critical of Salisbury’s handling of the coming together in the closing stages and believes the referee wanted to ‘make himself famous’ with his decision to send Dowman off.
‘Dowman has pushed him off him but he’s asked the referee to make a decision,’ Sherwood added.
‘He’s decided to make himself famous, “This boy could be special”, and he’ll be telling his grandkids, “I sent him off, you know! I sent him off, Max Dowman! Remember that? Fleetwood”, and his grandkids won’t believe him.’
Arsenal will look to quickly dust themselves off from their midweek upset ahead of their mouthwatering encounter away to Liverpool in the Premier League this weekend.
Arteta’s men sit second in the table ahead of Sunday’s showdown at Anfield, with Manchester City top of goal difference after eight games.